← reviews

Ethena held through the run on redemptions and came out a third of the size

the verdict
The test of a long downturn, still theoretical a year ago, has arrived: on the worst day the price came off the dollar and then came back. What didn’t come back is the size, down from fourteen to $4.52 billion, and the revenue followed it.
four measured every night, three judged every three months

How does a synthetic dollar stay still?

By holding two positions that cancel each other out. For every dollar of USDe issued, the protocol buys a dollar of spot collateral, from staked ether and bitcoin to other stablecoins, and opens a short of the same size on the perpetuals market.
spot collateral · +10%short · −10%sum: zero
if the collateral rises ten percent, the short loses the same: the two positions cancel out and the synthetic dollar stays still.

For every dollar of USDe issued, Ethena buys a dollar of spot collateral and opens a short of the same size on the perpetuals market: if the price rises ten percent the first position gains ten and the second loses ten, and the sum stays zero. It is this balance that lets it back every dollar issued with one dollar only, instead of the one and a half overcollateralized stablecoins require.

The sum is simple: if the collateral rises ten percent, the position it bought gains ten and the one it sold loses the same. The total stays at zero. That’s what lets Ethena back every dollar issued with a single dollar, where an overcollateralized stablecoin like DAI asks for one and a half.

The balance rests on one assumption, though: that the spot price and the perpetual price move together. In normal conditions it holds, because arbitrageurs keep them in line. But when an exchange halts trading or the liquidity dries up, the two prices come apart, and in those hours the hedge doesn’t hedge.

01 · measured

How much real adoption is left?

A third of what it had in October 2025: there’s $4.52 billion of USDe in circulation today, against fourteen back then.
14 billionOct 20255.92 billionMar 2026today · 4.52 billion
usde in circulation at the three moments that count: the october 2025 peak, the close of the first quarter, today. source: defillama · usde stablecoin, november 2, 2026.

The amount of USDe in circulation went from fourteen billion dollars in October 2025 to $5.92 billion at the close of the first quarter of 2026, and to $4.52 billion today: a contraction of 68% from the peak.

What deflated was the leverage, more than anything like a run. The positions built on top of the yield left: the ones where you deposit, borrow, deposit again and start over. The wallets holding USDe as a dollar stayed. sUSDe’s yield, meanwhile, is at 5%.

What’s left, though, is scaffolding a good part of decentralized finance now leans on: USDe is accepted as collateral by Aave, Pendle, Morpho and Curve, and unpicking those integrations costs more than keeping them. A protocol that deflates is a different thing from one that disappears.

02 · measured

Does the revenue hold when the market cools?

No, because the revenue comes entirely from the periodic payment between the people betting on a rise and the people betting on a fall, which the jargon calls funding. In the last closed quarter, the third quarter of 2026, the protocol collected $53.55 million gross, 65 percent less than in the third quarter of 2025, when USDe was at its peak.
151.08 millionthird quarter 202553.55 millionlast quarter
gross protocol revenue by quarter: the squeeze on the periodic payment is all here. source: defillama · ethena fees.

Gross protocol revenue went from $151.08 million in the third quarter of 2025, when USDe was at its peak, to $53.55 million in the third quarter of 2026: a fall of 65%.

Funding exists to keep the perpetual tied to the spot price. When lots of people buy with leverage, the perpetual trades above spot, and every eight hours the longs pay the shorts. Ethena, always on the short side, collects. When the optimism fades, the payment shrinks and the revenue with it.

Under that payment, though, there’s a base that doesn’t depend on the market’s mood: the part of the collateral held in staked ether earns three or four percent a year regardless. That’s why in June sUSDe’s yield fell to 7.1 percent without ever reaching zero.

03 · measured

How liquid is USDe on the day it counts?

Much less than it looks. On October 10, 2025, in the liquidation cascade that swept the whole market, Binance’s order book emptied and USDe changed hands at sixty-five cents. That’s thirty-five percent below its value, with the collateral intact.
$0.65
the low of October 10, 2025,
with the collateral intact
the low touched on binance’s order book on october 10, 2025, with the collateral full and the price back within hours.

On October 10, 2025 USDe touched $0.65 on Binance’s order book during the liquidation cascade, while remaining fully backed; the price came back within hours.

Being backed and being liquid are two different things. The collateral was all there, but at that moment the people who could have bought were closing their own positions, and the price went wherever the few remaining orders sent it. Whoever sold there really lost money; whoever waited got their dollar back.

This risk can’t be removed, because it depends more on the market where USDe trades than on Ethena. You can account for it, though: if you need money available at a moment’s notice, USDe isn’t the place to keep it.

04 · measured

How many counterparties does the collateral depend on?

Seven, and they’re not interchangeable. The collateral sits with three institutional custodians, while the hedge, meaning the shorts, is open on four centralized exchanges.
three custodiansfour exchangesthe collateral is herethe hedge is here
the collateral stays with the custodians; only the margin reaches the exchanges. when bybit suffered the billion-and-a-half theft, ethena had some thirty million there on derivatives, taken to zero the same day.

The collateral is deposited with three institutional custodians (Copper, Ceffu, Cobo) and never sits on the exchanges: it is pledged as margin at the four exchanges where the hedge is open (Binance, Bybit, OKX, Deribit). In February 2025 Bybit suffered a theft of about a billion and a half dollars: Ethena’s collateral was not on that exchange but with the custodian, and the residual derivatives exposure, around thirty million, was taken to zero the same day. Ethena suffered no losses.

Keeping them apart is the smartest thing they’ve done. Ethena doesn’t transfer the collateral to the exchanges. It pledges it as margin, and legal ownership stays with the custodian. If an exchange goes bust that collateral doesn’t end up in the bankruptcy estate.

And we already know it works. In February 2025 Bybit, one of the exchanges where Ethena held its hedge, suffered the biggest theft in the sector’s history, about a billion and a half dollars. Ethena’s collateral was with the custodian, and only some thirty million of derivatives margin was left on that exchange, and that was cut to zero the same day. Ethena lost nothing.

A real dependency remains, though. In a systemic crisis the trouble hits several exchanges at once, and in that case the hedge would turn into a claim to collect instead of a position to close.

05 · judged

Does the governance count for anything?

No. Whoever holds ENA votes on parameters and has no say over the money. They have no right to the revenue the protocol produces, and the fee switch that would give them a share has been under discussion for two years.
whoever holds sUSDewhoever holds enathe protocol’s revenue
where the protocol’s revenue goes: to whoever holds sUSDe, as yield. to whoever holds ena, for now, nothing.

The protocol’s revenue goes to whoever holds sUSDe in the form of yield; whoever holds ENA receives nothing by any settled arrangement, and the mechanism that would change the destination has been under discussion since 2024.

The fee switch stays off because of a real conflict, more than a technical problem. Sending a share of the revenue to token holders means taking it out of sUSDe’s yield, which weakens the only reason anyone prefers USDe to any other dollar. It’s the same money, the two sides are fighting over it, and so far the side that brings in customers has won.

This is a judgment and not a measurement, because there’s no sensible way to measure how real governance is. What you can see is that the important decisions have never gone through a vote: which exchanges to be on, how much to keep in the reserve fund and when to change collateral.

06 · judged

Does the team hold up?

Yes, and it’s the criterion this review is most generous on. In two and a half years Ethena has come through the theft at one of the exchanges it was exposed to and the worst liquidation cascade of the cycle, and both times the mechanism behaved the way the documentation promised.
Feb 2025a billion-and-a-half theft at bybit. ethena’s collateral was with the custodian; the thirty million of derivatives margin is taken to zero the same day, with no losses.
10 Oct 2025liquidation cascade. usde trades at $0.65 and comes back within hours.
Oct 25 – Mar 26the amount in circulation falls from fourteen to $5.92 billion. declared in the quarterly reports.

The tests come through: in February 2025 the billion-and-a-half theft suffered by Bybit, with Ethena exposed for some thirty million on derivatives and no losses; on 10 October 2025 the liquidation cascade, with USDe at $0.65 and the price back; between October 2025 and March 2026 the contraction from fourteen to $5.92 billion, declared in the quarterly reports.

And it told the story well. The fall from fourteen to $4.52 billion is in the quarterly reports, plainly written, and so is the drop in revenue. They also wrote about October’s depeg instead of pretending nothing had happened. In a sector where uncomfortable numbers disappear from press releases, that counts for something.

It’s a judgment, so it holds as long as the people who earned it stay. And in a system where the hedges have to be rebalanced across four exchanges around the clock, the team and the product are the same thing.

07 · judged

How much does the mechanism risk?

Medium risk, and this time the danger lies outside the code: the contract does one thing and anyone can check it. What can break is elsewhere: the periodic payment flipping and staying against it for months, the exchanges hosting the hedge, the chain of protocols that accepts USDe as collateral.

Against the first scenario there’s a declared defense: the protocol keeps five percent of that payment when it’s in its favor and sets it aside in a reserve fund. On the history available it holds, because even in the worst years the days when the payment went the other way were about one in ten. But that fund is sized for episodes lasting days, not months.

put bluntly
every time somebody launches a stablecoin yielding above ten percent, everyone screams “luna! ust! do kwon!”. it’s a knee-jerk reflex, and it has little to do with analysis

Put bluntly: every time a stablecoin offers a double-digit yield, the comparison with Luna and UST arrives before any analysis of the mechanism.

The difference from a year ago is that two scenarios have left the realm of theory: the cascade came and the price recovered, the attack on an exchange came and the exposure stayed marginal. What nobody has seen yet is the long scenario, months of negative payments in a row, which is the one case the reserve fund can’t cover.

the direct competitors, today
criterionethenaskyusual
in circulation$4.52bn $6.39bn$540m
capital backing$4.53bn $5.04bn$80m
fees, 30 days$17.21m $28.35m$0.35m
the same measured criteria on the direct competitors, all taken today from the same source: defillama, november 2, 2026.

Comparison between ethena and its direct competitors in the same category, on the measured criteria, all taken on november 2, 2026 from the same source (defillama). In circulation: ethena $4.52bn, sky $6.39bn, usual $540m. Capital backing: ethena $4.53bn, sky $5.04bn, usual $80m. Fees, 30 days: ethena $17.21m, sky $28.35m, usual $0.35m.

how it updates

this review updates itself, within declared limits

the 4 measured criteria are recomputed with the same procedure as on day one. the 3 judgments are not: those are revisited by hand.
rhythmdata every night · judgments every three months early triggerthe review is triggered early if the supply moves by more than 30%, if funding stays negative for more than thirty days, or after a depeg beyond two percentage points nextby November 2026 checkedAugust 18, 2026 last recomputedNovember 2, 2026
the words in this piece · 19
book
the list of buy and sell orders waiting on a market. the thicker it is, the more liquid that market is.
collateral
what you leave as security for the loan. if its price falls too far, they sell it to close the debt.
custodian
the specialist operator that holds funds on somebody else’s behalf, kept separate from its own.
depeg
when a stablecoin stops being worth what the currency it is pegged to is worth.
exchange
the platform where cryptocurrency is traded. centralized if it holds the clients’ funds, decentralized if the trades happen onchain.
fee
what you pay to use a protocol. it can go to whoever supplies the service, to whoever holds the token, or to both.
fee switch
the switch that diverts part of the fees from the liquidity providers to the protocol or to whoever holds its token. turning it on is almost always a political decision, not a technical one.
funding
the periodic payment between whoever bets on a rise and whoever bets on a fall on a perpetual contract. it exists to keep that contract’s price tied to the spot market.
governance
the set of rules by which decisions get made about a protocol: who proposes, who votes, who executes.
liquidation
the forced sale of the collateral when the debt gets too big against the security behind it.
long
the position that gains when the price rises.
order book
the list of every offer to buy and to sell: the traditional way a price is made.
perpetual
the contract that follows a coin’s price without ever expiring: to stay open you pay or collect the funding.
short
the position that gains when the price falls. you open it by selling something you don’t own.
spot
the market where the asset itself changes hands, delivered on the spot. as opposed to derivatives, where what trades is a contract.
stablecoin
a token built to be worth the same as a currency, usually the dollar. what changes is how it manages that: reserves at a bank, collateral onchain, hedges on derivatives.
token holder
whoever holds a protocol’s token. it isn’t the same set of people as whoever uses it, and that is where a lot of the conflict comes from.
wallet
the program that keeps the keys a transaction is signed with. it doesn’t hold the funds: it holds the permission to move them.
yield
what a deployed capital earns, written as a yearly percentage.
review · ethena · reassessed 18 Aug 2026all the reviews